الگویی برای شناسایی و تبیین مضامین حسابداری خلاقانه: با رویکرد تحلیل مضمون و دیمتل فازی

نوع مقاله : مقاله پژوهشی

نویسندگان

1 دانشجوی دکتری گروه حسابداری ، واحد کاشان، دانشگاه آزاد اسلامی، کاشان، ایران.

2 گروه حسابداری، واحد بندرگز دانشگاه آزاد اسلامی ، بندرگز، ایران.

3 استادیار گروه حسابداری ، واحد کاشان،دانشگاه آزاد اسلامی، کاشان ،ایران.

4 استادیار گروه حسابداری ، واحد کاشان،دانشگاه آزاد اسلامی، کاشان ،ایران

10.22099/jaa.2023.47654.2344

چکیده

هدف این مطالعه، اکتشاف و بسط مضامین شناسایی شده‌ی حسابداری خلاقانه براساس ارزیابی فرآیند فازی دیمتل (FDEMATEL) می‌باشد. این مطالعه به لحاظ نوع جمع آوری داده ها ترکیبی است. در بخش کیفی این مطالعه از تحلیل تماتیک بهره برده شده است و طی سه مرحله کدگذاری، ابعاد مدل تدوین گردید. سپس در بخش کمی ابتدا از طریق تحلیل دلفی فازی ابتدا پایایی مولفه‌های شناسایی شده مورد بررسی قرار گرفت و سپس از طریق تحلیل فازی دیمتل نسبت به تعیین تأثیرگذارترین مضامین شناسایی شده در حسابداری خلاقانه‌ی شرکت‌های بازار سرمایه اقدام گردید. جامعه هدف در بخش کیفی ۱2 نفر از خبرگان حسابداری و اساتید دانشگاهی بودند که چه به لحاظ علمی و چه به لحاظ تجربی، خبره تلقی می‌شدند. نمونه‌گیری در بخش روش شناسی کیفی، نمونه‌گیری نظری و نحوه تعیین نمونه گلوله برفی بود. اما جامعه هدف در بخش کمی 30 نفر از مدیران مالی شرکت‌های بورسی بودند، که براساس تجربه‌های کاری و سطح دانش فنی و تخصصی از طریق نمونه‌گیری همگن انتخاب شدند. نتایج پژوهش در بخش کیفی از وجودِ ۳ مضمون فراگیر؛ ۶ مضمون سازمان دهنده و 36 مضمون پایه در قالب چارچوب تماتیک ۶ بعدی حکایت داشت که طی سه مرحله کدگذاری آترید-استرلینگ (۲۰۰۱) اکتشاف شدند. نتایج در بخش کمی نشان داد، براساس فرآیند فازی دیمتل سه معیار A1 (عینیت‌گرایی ذاتی مبنای حسابداری خلاقانه)، A4 (ضعف کنترل داخلی مبنای حسابداری خلاقانه) و A6 (ضعف آینده‌نگری مبنای حسابداری خلاقانه)، نسبت به سایر مولفه‌های شناسایی شده از تحریک زمینه‌ای بالاتری در حسابداری خلاقانه‌ی شرکت‌های بازار سرمایه برخوردار می‌باشند.

کلیدواژه‌ها

موضوعات


عنوان مقاله [English]

A Model for Identifying and Explaining the Themes of Creative Accounting: with the Approach of Thematic Analysis and Fuzzy DEMATEL

نویسندگان [English]

  • Farzaneh Mohammadi 1
  • mehdi safari gerayli 2
  • Meysam Arabzadeh 3
  • Ali Akbar Farzinfar 4
1 PH.D Student Department of Accounting, Kashan Branch, Islamic Azad University, Kashan, Iran.
2 Department of accounting, Bandargaz Branch, Islamic Azad University, Bandargaz, Iran
3 Assistant Prof Department of Accounting, Kashan Branch, Islamic Azad University, Kashan, Iran
4 Assistant Prof Department of Accounting, Kashan Branch, Islamic Azad University, Kashan, Iran
چکیده [English]

Introduction
Due to the turmoil caused by the manipulation of financial statements, the capital markets are facing a large amount of mistrust among shareholders and investors, and even in the presence of strict reporting standards, violations and planned financial distortions can still be witnessed (Ndegwa, 2023). One of these inefficient aspects of capital markets is creative accounting, which under the influence of behavioral and structural drivers can develop the fields of information disclosure distortion in an opportunistic manner in the functions of capital market companies (Goto & Yamamoto, 2023). The emergence of such a process in terms of accounting procedures and information disclosure, as mentioned, increases the scope of mistrust in the capital markets, and it seems that reaching the point of understanding the reasons for the emergence of this method of accounting can prevent the behavioral opportunism of companies (Vollmer, 2023). In other words, creative accounting is a kind of financially conscious behavior to avoid reducing the sustainable interests of companies against the decisions of investors who use the gap in standards for their own benefit, which may face a strong reaction from shareholders in the long run due to hiding aspects of the company's performance (Rahman et al, 2023).
 
 
Research Hypothesis
 
Creative accounting is considered as a process or strategy in the way of implementation, which, although it is in line with accounting rules and standards, due to the deepening of the agency cost, it is far away from the functional realities, and it reflects the news and distorted information of the results in favor of the owners. Power is in the company and at the expense of external users. On the other hand, creative accounting is usually complicated by excessive opportunism in using new methods to describe income. It faces an asset or a liability whose purpose is to influence users and manipulate their interpretations in line with the goals of those in power (Supriya & Vidhi, 2018). A review of the roots of this concept in accounting shows that the terms "innovative" or "aggressive" have been used to describe this method of accounting by studies such as Amat & Gowthorpe (2004) and Cernusca et al (2016), which shows that the concept is emerging, almost due to the lack of specific dimensions, and no clear the contexts of its formation. The main purpose for creating creative accounting is to "distort the facts through the manipulation of the company's profits or costs, which is done to satisfy the possessive interests of a group of people with power."
 
 
Research Methods
 
This study is developmental in terms of results, because there is no coherent framework for the development of the concept of creative accounting in accounting functions, and this study, through a set of scientific methods, seeks to compile and explain the dimensions of the creative accounting model at the level of capital market companies. In terms of purpose, this research, relying on the thematic analysis process and Fuzzy DEMATEL, seeks to evaluate the organizational themes identified in the context of capital market companies. The research approach of the current study, in terms of the logic of data collection, is of a hybrid type; because it investigates a phenomenon about which there is no comprehensive framework in the theoretical fields of accounting at the level of capital market functions, or it is not a consensus. Therefore, first, through the analysis of the qualitative part and relying on the thematic analysis method, an effort is made to determine the dimensions of the creative accounting model in the form of a multidimensional model based on overarching themes; organizer and base provided. After presenting the model and measuring the reliability of its dimensions through Delphi analysis, this study seeks to evaluate the internal relationships of the identified dimensions of the model in the context of capital market companies in a quantitative analysis through Fuzzy DEMATEL.
 
 
Result
 
Based on the current concept in this research, considering that there is no coherent framework about creative accounting, it is first used through qualitative analysis methods to select research components and determine its reliability. Thematic analysis is considered as the executive process of content analysis, which analyzes the basics and concepts of the current topic through simultaneous content analysis in similar studies and conducting interviews to determine its dimensions. In this study, the typology of thematic analysis based on the style of Attride-Stirling (2001) has been used. By following this method, the basic theme shows an important point in the text, and by combining them, the organizing theme is created. The organizing theme is the interface of the overarching themes and the base of the network, and the overarching theme is placed at the center of the theme network. Therefore, at this stage, theme analysis was used for the interview to determine the basic and organizing themes of creative accounting as overarching themes. Therefore, according to the overarching theme of this study, which was creative accounting, a total of 3 overarching themes, 6 organizing themes, and 37 basic themes were created from 12 interviews. It was also determined, based on Fuzzy DEMATEL's technique, that lack of attention to the needs of financial legal knowledge to improve the knowledge of the consequences of creative accounting (C30) as an indicator of educational weakness of the basis of creative accounting "A5" and duality of duty (C17) as an indicator of the type of ownership of the basis of creative accounting "A3" and agency cost (C9) are known as the inherent theorization index of the basis of creative accounting "A2", which is considered to have the most stimulation in the occurrence of creative accounting compared to other features based on this analysis.
 
 
Conclusion
 
The purpose of this research is Exploration and Development of Creative Accounting Identified Themes: Evaluation based on FDEMATEL Process. In the analysis of the obtained results, it should be stated that the element of objectivity inherent in the basis of creative accounting refers to the fact that the distortion of financial information is inherent in the nature of classical accounting methods, because of the measurement of information in the rules of financial standards. The qualitative aspects of information disclosure and accounting procedures are not disclosed, and focus on the benefits of reporting, only the reflected aspects of the financial performance of companies to stakeholders can be measured. Such a process can reduce information values for stakeholders and lead to their one-dimensional perception of information disclosure according to what companies reflect to them. On the other hand, the weakness of internal control, the basis of creative accounting, is considered another axis of distortion of financial information, which refers to the appointment of internal controls in the financial structure of companies, which can lead to the lack of independence of the internal control elements and prevent the accurate assessment of the company's risk and independent functions of the internal audit committee.
 
 
 
 

کلیدواژه‌ها [English]

  • Creative Accounting
  • FDEMATEL Process
  • Thematic Analysis
منابع
الف.فارسی
احمدی، فضل‌اله.، نصیریانی، خدیجه.، اباذری، پروانه. (1387). تکنیک دلفی: ابزاری در تحقیق. مجله ایرانی آموزش در علوم پزشکی،  ۸(۱)، ۱۷۵-۱۸۵
چهارده‌چریکی، معصومه.، بولو، قاسم.، رئیسی‌وانانی، ایمان.، باباجانی، جعفر.، تقوی‌فرد، محمدتقی. (1401). شناسایی و رتبه‌بندی شاخص‌های حسابداری خلاقانه با استفاده از تکنیک فرآیند تحلیل شبکه‌ای، حسابداری و منافع اجتماعی، 12(1)، 21-40
حاجیها، زهره.، شبانی، حبیب. (1391). تفکر خلاق و انتقادی در حسابداری اسلامی، حسابداری و منافع اجتماعی، 2(2)، 59-75.
حمیدیان، نرگس. (1401). تاثیر هم‌حرکتی سود بر احتمال دستکاری سود با در نظر گرفتن رقابت بازار محصول، پیشرفت‌های حسابداری، 14(2)، 69-84.
قشقایی، علی.، بیگلر، کیومرث. (۱۳۹۸). جایگاه حسابداری خلاقانه در بین حسابرسان ایران با تاکید بر آیین اخلاق و رفتار حرفه‌ای حسابرسی، نشریه چشم‌انداز حسابداری و مدیریت، ۲(۲۰)، ۱۰۰-۱۱۳.
مشکی‌میاوقی، مهدی، خردیار، سینا.، حسن‌زاده، نغمه. (1397). بررسی رابطه بین استراتژی راهبری هزینه، رقابت بازار و مدیریت سود‌های واقعی در شرکت‌های پذیرفته شده در بورس اوراق بهادار تهران، پیشرفت‌های حسابداری، 10(1)، 218-243.
نمازی، نویدرضا، صالحی، تابنده. (1401). شناسایی و رتبه‌بندی روش‌های یادگیری فعال در آموزش حسابداری با استفاده از فرآیند تحلیل سلسله مراتبی فازی ( ). حسابداری و منافع اجتماعی، 12(3): 45-70.
ب. انگلیسی
Abed, I, A., Hussin, N., Ali, M, A., Haddad, H., Shehadeh, M., Hasan, E, F. (2022). Creative Accounting Determinants and Financial Reporting Quality: Systematic Literature Review, Risks, MDPI, 10(4): 1-25
Adámiková, E., Čorejová, T. (2021). Creative Accounting and the Possibility of Its Detection in the Evaluation of the Company by Expert, JRFM, MDPI, 14(7): 1-12.
Ahmadi, F., Nasiriani, Kh., Abazari, P. (2008). Delphi technique: a tool in research. Iranian Journal of Education in Medical Sciences, 8(1), 175-185 (In Persian)
Akpanuko, E.E. and Umoren, N.J. (2018). The influence of creative accounting on the credibility of accounting reports, Journal of Financial Reporting and Accounting, 16(2): 292-310. Amat, O., Gowthorpe, C. (2004). Creative Accounting: Nature, Incidence and Ethical Issues (April 2004). UPF Working Paper No. 749, Available at SSRN: https://ssrn.com/abstract=563364 or http://dx.doi.org/10.2139/ssrn.563364
Amat, O., Gowthorpe, C. (2004). Creative Accounting: Nature, Incidence and Ethical Issues (April 2004). UPF Working Paper No. 749, Available at SSRN: https://ssrn.com/abstract=563364 or http://dx.doi.org/10.2139/ssrn.563364
Balaciu, D., Bogdan, V., Vladu, A, B. (2009). A brief review of creative accounting literature and its consequences in practice. Annales Universitatis Apulensis Series Oeconomica, 11(1): 35-51.
Blazek, R., Durana, P. and Michulek, J. (2023). Renaissance of Creative Accounting Due to the Pandemic: New Patterns Explored by Correspondence Analysis, Stats, 6(1): 411-430. https://doi.org/10.3390/stats6010025
Cernusca, L., David, D., Nicolaescu, C., & Gomoi, B. (2016). Empirical Study on the Creative Accounting Phenomenon. Studia Universitatis Vasile Goldis” Arad Economics Series, 26 (2). Glaser, B. G. (1992). Theoretical Sensitivity: Advances in the methodology of grounded theory. Mill Valley, Calif.: Sociology Press.
Chahrdahcheriki, M., Blue, G., Raeisi Vanani, I., Babajani, J., & Taghavifard, M. T. (2022). Identifying and Ranking creative accounting Indicators Using Analytic Network Process. Journal of Accounting and Social Interests12(1), 21-40. (In Persian)
Chandra, D. and Kumar, D. (2020). Prioritizing the vaccine supply chain issues of developing countries using an integrated ISM-fuzzy ANP framework, Journal of Modelling in Management, 15(1): 112-165. https://doi.org/10.1108/JM2-08-2018-0111
Dinçer, H., Bozaykut-Buk, T., Emir, Ş., Yuksel, S. and Ashill, N. (2020). Using the fuzzy multicriteria decision making approach to evaluate brand equity: a study of privatized firms, Journal of Product & Brand Management, 29(3): 335-354. https://doi.org/10.1108/JPBM-09-2018-2037
Gashqai, A. & Biglar, K. (2020). The place of creative accounting among Iranian auditors With an emphasis on ethics and professional behavior. Journal of Accounting and Management Vision, 2(20), 100-113. (In Persian)
Goto, T., Yamamoto, G. (2023). Debt issuance incentives and creative accounting: Evidence from municipal mergers in Japan, Journal of the Japanese and International Economies, 68(1): 19-35.
Gupta, C.M. and Kumar, D. (2020). Creative accounting a tool for financial crime: a review of the techniques and its effects, Journal of Financial Crime, 27(2): 397-411.
Gupta, N., Vrat, P. and Ojha, R. (2022). Prioritizing enablers for service quality in healthcare sector – a DEMATEL approach, Journal of Health Organization and Management, 36(5): 633-649.
Hajiha, Z., & Shabani, H. (2012). Creative and critical thinking in Islamic accounting. Journal of Accounting and Social Interests2(2), 59-75. (In Persian)
Hamidian, N. (2023). The effect of earnings co-movement on the probability of earnings manipulation: by considering product market competition. Journal of Accounting Advances14(2), 69-84. (In Persian)
Henwood, K. L. & Pigeon, N, R. (1992). Qualitative research and psychological theorizing. British Journal of Psychology, 83(1): 97-112.
Jonsen, K. and Jehn, K.A. (2009). Using triangulation to validate themes in qualitative studies, Qualitative Research in Organizations and Management, 4(2): 123-150.
Lin, K, P., Wen, W., Chou, Ch., Jen, Ch, H., Hung, K, Ch. (2011). Applying fuzzy GERT with approximate fuzzy arithmetic based on the weakest t-norm operations to evaluate repairable reliability, Applied Mathematical Modelling, 35(11): 5314-5325
Luthra, S., Garg, D., Haleem, A. (2014). Green supply chain management. Implementation and performance - A literature review and some issues, Journal of Advances in Management Research, 11(01):20-46.
Marilena, Z., Corina, I. (2012). Embellishment of Financial Statements through Creative Accounting Policies and Options, Procedia - Social and Behavioral Sciences, 62(1): 46-69.
MeshkiMiavagii, M., Kheradyar, S., & Hasanzadeh, N. (2018). A study on the relationship between Cost leadership strategy, Market Competition, and earnings management in the Tehran Stock Exchange (TSE). Journal of Accounting Advances10(1), 218-243. (In Persian)
Namazi, N. R., & Salehi, T. (2022). Identify and Ranking Active Learning Methods in Accounting Education Using the Fuzzy Analysis Hierarchy Process. Journal of Accounting and Social Interests, 12(3), 45-70. (In Persian)
Ndebugri, H. and Senzu, E, T. (2017). Analyzing the critical effects of creative accounting practices in the corporate sector of Ghana, Munich Personal RePEc Archive (MPRA), 81(2): 113-132.
Ndegwa, J. N. (2023). Do markets react to corporate governance reforms? Evidence from a developing economy, Corporate Governance, 23(2): 422-439.
Olojede, P., Erin, O. (2021). Corporate governance mechanisms and creative accounting practices: the role of accounting regulation, International Journal of Disclosure and Governance, 18(2): 207–222
Oyedokun, G, E. (2018). Any Justification for Creative Accounting: Where Are Fraud, Examiners?, http://dx.doi.org/10.2139/ssrn.3272415
Rahman, M, Sh., Hasan, J., Hossain Khan, Sh., Jahan, I. (2023). Antecedents and effect of creative accounting practices on organizational outcomes: Evidence from Bangladesh, Heliyon, 9(2): 75-92.
Rajput, S. and Singh, S.P. (2019). Identifying Industry 4.0 IoT enablers by integrated PCA-ISM-DEMATEL approach, Management Decision, 57(8): 1784-1817. Saleh, M, M, A., Jawabreh, O., Abu-Eker, E, F, M. (2021). Factors of applying creative accounting and its impact on the quality of financial statements in Jordanian hotels, sustainable practices, Journal of Sustainable Finance & Investment, https://doi.org/10.1080/20430795.2021.1962662
Supriya, Kh., Vidhi, B. (2018). A Comprehensive Review of Literature on Creative Accounting, International Journal of Business Insights and Transformation, 10(1): 46-60.
SUSMUŞ, T., DEMİRHAN, D. (2020). Creative Accounting: A Brief History and Conceptual Framework, AKADEMİK BAKIŞ DERGİSİ, 2(3): 1-20.
Tanaka, W., Iwasaki, M. (2023). Homogeneity and Heterogeneity in How Institutional Investors Perceive Corporate and Securities Regulations, European Business Organization Law Review, 2(2): 163-189. https://doi.org/10.1007/s40804-022-00260-4
Ustinova, Y., Gupta, Ch, M., Shaposhnikov, A. (2022). Creative Accounting Detection Methods: Foreign Experience, Advances in Social Science, Education and Humanities Research, 632(2): 193-219.
Vollmer, H. (2023). Accounting theory, ethnography, and the silence of the social, Qualitative Research in Accounting & Management, https://doi.org/10.1108/QRAM-09-2022-0145